Shareholder Activists Hit Starbucks on Recycling

March 25, 2010 at 4:43 pm | Posted in Shareholder Advocacy | 1 Comment

By Dale Wannen

As I stood and watched the line of 12 in front of me at Starbucks the other day, I daydreamed about the load of cups Starbucks must go through every day.  A little googling turned up the fact that  it’s actually 3 billion paper cups and 1 billion plastic cups a year.  To put that in tangible terms, that’s 8,219,178 paper cups and 2,739,726 plastic cups a day.  Wait, 10 million cups a day?

While I wait for those of you who spewed hot lattes onto your laptops to clean up after yourselves, please be assured certain groups are doing something about this.  Starbucks annual shareholder meeting just ended Wednesday in Seattle.  This meeting was entertainment infused:  Sheryl Crow sang some of her hits and informed the crowd that she “drinks Starbucks coffee every morning” (something tells me we will be hearing more Sheryl at our local Starbucks). But that’s not all. There was shareholder activism to witness.  As You Sow Foundation , a shareholder advocacy organization  put forth a proposal using shareholder advocate John Harrington’s shares [Full Disclosure: he’s my boss], asking the board of directors to adopt a comprehensive recycling strategy for beverage containers.  Although those baristas can stir up a mean mocha,  Starbucks as a whole has a poor record when addressing recycling issues.

Starbucks makes the argument that they have no control over recycling.  Their excuse…local governments control the waste stream system.  As a paperboy in my younger years, I would be late on deliveries sometimes.  Making excuses for this behavior didn’t work, and my clients would show this in the 50 cent tips I received.  In the same terms, Starbucks shouldn’t be making excuses. They should be positioning themselves as a leader for change.  Eleven percent of shareholders voted in favor of As You Sow’s proposal which equates to over 42 million out of the 740 million shares outstanding shares saying yes.

Other issues that As You Sow Foundation confronted were the lack of recycled content in their ETHOS water bottles.  If you have noticed, this water is marketed as a way to help children get clean water and Starbucks has contributed over $6 millon to water stressed countries through sales of it.  That’s all well and good, but serving out non-recycled content plastic bottles by the millions isn’t going to help these children in the long run.  By putting at least 10% of recycled plastic into the bottles, they would simply be matching their competitors Coca-Cola and Pepsi in their strict recycling mandates.  Next time you sip on that Iced White Chocolate Mocha or grab that bottle of water while Sheryl Crow blares from the speakers, ask the barista if you can use a ceramic cup instead.


1 Comment »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. Nice post!

    The website Sustainability Is Sexy has a useful page on the environmental impacts of paper cups here:

    I would love to see Starbucks (and my own neighborhood cafes, for that matter!) raise awareness of to-go mugs and give customers greater incentives to bring them.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: